Beloved Portobello cinema could be demolished despite listed building status

The former George Cinema

The potential demolition of a much-loved former cinema in Portobello has raised questions over the utility of listed building status.

The George opened in 1939 a short walk from the beachfront, and screened its last film in 1974.

It was subsequently operated as a bingo hall before closing in 2016 after being bought over by new owners, 

A written submission from the owner of the building went before the City of Edinburgh Council planning committee on November 12 of 2025, requesting permission to demolish the Category C listed building.

Owners Buckley Building said they have “made repeated and food-faith attempts to work within planning procedures to develop this building”, but that it now presents a danger to the public and must be demolished.

They argue that the building is unsafe and “impregnated with asbestos”.

On November 9 of this year, a planning application was submitted by Buckley Building for the demolition after a legal judgment in favour of the group.

In an accompanying statement, the owners argue that “there is no reasonable alternative” to demolition.

Efforts to save the building have been spearheaded by a local group, Friends of the George, who wanted City of Edinburgh Council to issue a defective building notice, which forces owners to fix significant defects before a building deteriorates further.

That was done on February 4 this year, but Buckley appealed and Sheriff Nicol upheld the appeal, stating that “it is highly likely that the building is objectively beyond repair” but made clear it was ultimately up to City of Edinburgh Council to decide whether or not it is dangerous.

While no final decision has been made, it appears likely that a demolition will ultimately take place, raising questions over the fitness for purpose of the listing system.

SNP MSP Kate Campbell wrote in the Edinburgh Evening News: “How was a C-listed building allowed to get into this state?

“This building has huge community backing alongside a dedicated team of local people. They’re skilled and experienced in architecture, design and running listed buildings as community facilities.

“In our meeting with planning officials this week one resident asked what the point is in having listed buildings if there isn’t anything we can do to protect them. And it’s a question being asked across Scotland.

“If people are allowed to own listed buildings, not maintain them and once they reach a state of disrepair, demolish them – what is the value of a listing?

“Edinburgh Council will need to reflect on what it could have done differently. I’m also exploring what changes we could make to strengthen the law.

“But there’s still hope for the George – no final decision has been made. The process must be transparent, decided by democratically elected councillors and with evidence about the condition of the building available publicly.

“Residents can help by formally objecting to the demolition, making it clear just how much this building means to us all.”

Responding to a question from Campbell in the Scottish Parliament this week, First Minister John Swinney said: “There are a number of properties, and the George Cinema in Portobello is one example, that will be important for our built heritage but are in private ownership and are not being cared for in the way we would all want to see.

“In March this year, the Government published updated guidance on dealing with listed buildings that become dangerous. That guidance makes it clear that responsibility for the maintenance and upkeep of such buildings rests with their owners, who must comply with relevant legal requirements, and local authorities are responsible for taking enforcement action where appropriate.

Kate Campbell’s point, which has significant validity, is that, if an owner is not doing that but the building does not quite pass the test for being a dangerous building or posing a risk to the public, there is scope for us to explore what further intervention could be taken forward by local authorities.”