Scotland’s growing film and television industry could face a new challenge from Hollywood as the United States considers tax breaks designed to bring major productions back to America.
Creative industries minister Ian Murray has warned that the proposed changes could threaten the UK’s ability to attract international productions, with potentially significant implications for Scotland’s studios, production companies and thousands of workers.
The Edinburgh South MP, who previously served as Scottish Secretary, addressed the issue at the British Screen Forum conference in London on Thursday.
Speaking about the proposed American tax incentives, Murray said: “The outcome remains to be seen in detail, but we take the implications incredibly seriously.”
He warned that other countries were increasingly competing for a share of the UK’s film and television industry: “By placing the creative industries at the heart of our industrial strategy, the government has already shown that we will stand with the sector to face those challenges head on. By working together, we can protect what was good about the sector and build towards bright and exciting new horizons. As we do that together, this government has your back,” he told the audience.
“There’s not another country in the world that doesn’t look enviously on the UK film, TV, and gaming sectors, but they do want to eat our lunch.”
His intervention follows the introduction of bipartisan legislation in the United States that would create a federal tax credit for film and television productions using American workers.
The proposed scheme would offer a 20 per cent credit on qualifying US labour costs, potentially increasing to 30 per cent through additional incentives.
Productions would generally need to carry out at least 75 per cent of their principal photography days in the United States to qualify.
The federal incentive could also operate alongside existing state-level tax breaks, potentially making American studios more competitive against established filming destinations such as Scotland.
For Scotland, the stakes are considerable.
The country has become an increasingly important location for major international productions, building an industry around established studios, skilled crews and a landscape that has provided the backdrop for some of television’s biggest successes.
Outlander has been central to that growth, with its production base at Wardpark Studios in Cumbernauld supporting employment across a wide range of specialist trades.
Edinburgh has also established itself as a production centre. FirstStage Studios in Leith has hosted projects including The Rig and Netflix’s Dept Q.
Dept Q
Major productions bring investment extending well beyond studio walls, with spending on accommodation, transport, catering, construction and local services.
The concern is that Hollywood studios could become more reluctant to move productions overseas if the financial benefits of filming at home become substantially greater.
He also ruled out any immediate changes to the current UK system but said the rates are always kept under review.
“They’re simplistic, they’re not capped, and therefore we have a really good ecosystem,” he said of the UK’s range of film and high-end TV reliefs.
Murray acknowledged the scale of that challenge when he appeared before the House of Commons Culture, Media and Sport Committee on 11 November.
Discussing Britain’s existing production incentives, he said: “We have to keep these under review all the time.”
He specifically identified the proposed American federal incentive, which could be combined with other tax credits, as a significant challenge for the UK.
The UK currently offers an expenditure credit of 34 per cent on qualifying costs for most eligible films and high-end television productions, alongside an enhanced 53 per cent rate for qualifying independent films.
Those advantages have helped the UK become one of the world’s leading production centres.
The Government is also introducing measures to strengthen the wider screen industry, including a £75 million Screen Growth Package and support for production infrastructure and training.
Murray told the conference that ministers were working to attract private finance to the sector, recognising that access to investment remained an important challenge for production companies.
The debate comes at a difficult time for the film and television industry.
Figures published by the British Film Institute this month showed that combined spending on film and high-end television production fell to £5.18 billion in the 12 months to September 2026, a decline of 20 per cent compared with the previous 12-month period.
The downturn predates the introduction of any new US federal incentive and reflects wider pressures on production budgets and commissioning.
Nevertheless, the potential for additional American tax breaks has heightened concerns about the future flow of international investment.
Scotland’s screen industry generated £718 million in gross value added in 2023, according to research commissioned by Screen Scotland, supporting the equivalent of 12,260 full-time jobs.
An estimated £468.3 million was spent on film, television and other audiovisual production in Scotland during that year.
Screen Scotland has set a target for the sector to contribute £1 billion annually to the Scottish economy by the end of 2030/31.
The challenge is maintaining that momentum in an increasingly competitive international market.
Scotland has considerable strengths, including its experienced workforce, established production facilities, historic cities and distinctive landscapes.
Productions such as Outlander also demonstrate the economic value of developing long-term relationships with international broadcasters and studios.
However, projects that do not specifically require Scottish locations may be more vulnerable to decisions based on production costs.
The issue comes as Holyrood prepares to examine the future of Scotland’s screen industry.
The Scottish Parliament’s Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee launched an inquiry on Friday into Screen Scotland, including its effectiveness in attracting productions, developing skills and helping the industry grow.
The inquiry will also consider the Scottish Government’s plans to establish Screen Scotland as an independent body.
For the thousands of people working in Scotland’s film and television sector, the concern is that the financial calculations behind future projects could soon become more challenging.
With Hollywood studios able to choose between competing destinations around the world, Scotland will be hoping its production infrastructure, skilled workforce and established international reputation can continue to attract investment.