NHS Scotland chief faces questions over handling of warnings before deaths scandal

A senior NHS executive helping to shape the future of Scotland’s health service rejected a request for an investigation into hospital management shortly before a report identified 19 avoidable patient deaths.

Professor Caroline Hiscox, who was chief executive of NHS Grampian at the time, was asked in September 2022 to investigate the medical directorate at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary.

The request came from consultant surgeon Dr Mohammed Meer Habib, who had been raising concerns about patient safety and surgical deaths at the hospital.

Emails obtained by The Sunday Times reveal that Hiscox responded through another manager, who said an investigation into the directorate was “neither proportionate nor appropriate” at that time.

Less than two weeks later, an independent review of liver and pancreatic surgery identified 19 deaths that were considered avoidable.

The findings of the review, which examined 45 cases, were not made public at the time.

The revelations raise fresh questions about the handling of warnings at NHS Grampian and the accountability of senior executives responsible for patient safety.

Hiscox, who left NHS Grampian in 2023, is now chief executive of NHS Lothian and chairs the NHS Scotland Executive Group.

She has also been involved in discussions about the Scottish Government’s plans to restructure the health service, including proposals to replace Scotland’s 14 territorial health boards with two strategic bodies.

The latest allegations come as Health Secretary Angela Constance has ordered an urgent independent review into how concerns about surgical care at NHS Grampian were handled.

The investigation will examine the actions of health board executives, Scottish Government officials and ministers, including when warnings were received and what action followed.

Dr Habib went public with his concerns on Thursday, claiming that patients had died needlessly and alleging a failure by senior figures to respond adequately to repeated warnings.

The consultant, who continues to work at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary, has called for a criminal investigation into NHS Grampian and a public inquiry.

He has alleged that hundreds of patients may have suffered significant harm or avoidable deaths over a number of years.

The previously unpublished 2022 review examined liver and pancreatic surgery carried out between 2015 and 2021. Among 31 patients who died, 19 deaths were assessed as avoidable.

The allegations have intensified scrutiny of the health board following a separate critical report by Healthcare Improvement Scotland earlier this month.

That investigation identified serious weaknesses in leadership, clinical governance and the management of medical staff across NHS Grampian.

Scottish Labour health spokeswoman Dame Jackie Baillie said the latest disclosures raised serious questions about what Hiscox knew during her time leading the health board.

She called for an explanation of whether concerns had been communicated to Scottish ministers or Police Scotland.

NHS Lothian defended the actions taken during Hiscox’s leadership of NHS Grampian.

A spokesperson said an independent review of concerns relating to hepatobiliary surgery had been commissioned, with findings reported to Scottish Government officials, the health secretary and through the board’s governance procedures.

The spokesperson said recommendations were implemented, progress was reported to the clinical governance committee and independent reviews of individual cases were undertaken.

They added that affected families had been contacted and offered support, while Hiscox had also commissioned a separate investigation into related employment matters in December 2021.

The growing controversy prompted Constance to announce a fresh independent investigation on Saturday.

She said: “The allegations that have been raised by Dr Habib are deeply concerning and of the utmost seriousness.”

The review will seek to establish who knew about the concerns, when they became aware of them and whether opportunities to intervene were missed.

It will also examine the Scottish Government’s handling of correspondence and the adequacy of information provided to ministers.

First Minister John Swinney has instructed officials to preserve potentially relevant records to ensure they are available to investigators.

Any evidence suggesting an immediate patient safety risk, potential criminality or serious professional misconduct will be referred to the appropriate authorities without waiting for the review’s final findings.

NHS Grampian chief executive Laura Skaife-Knight has welcomed the investigation and pledged that the health board will cooperate fully.

She said it was essential to establish whether concerns raised between 2012 and 2026 had been properly investigated and appropriate action taken.

Constance is expected to make a statement to the Scottish Parliament on Tuesday, 24 November, setting out further details of the review, including its leadership, scope and timetable.