Police probe into NHS Grampian deaths after surgeon claims patients died needlessly

Police have launched an investigation into claims that patients died needlessly at a Scottish hospital.

The probe comes after a whistleblower surgeon accused NHS bosses of covering up a string of avoidable deaths.

Consultant Dr Mohammed Meer Habib claimed operating theatres at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary were like a “slaughterhouse” where patients died through incompetence and negligence.

The senior medic, who has 36 years’ experience, alleged hundreds of patients may have suffered significant harm or avoidable deaths in recent years.

He has demanded a corporate homicide investigation after revealing details of an unpublished 2022 expert review which identified 19 avoidable deaths among 45 cases undergoing liver and pancreatic surgery.

Dr Habib claimed some patients bled to death on the operating table because of surgical mistakes, while two others were said to have died after receiving the wrong operations.

Police Scotland confirmed officers were investigating following a report in 2024.

Detective Superintendent Carron McKellar said: “We received a report in 2024 following several deaths.

“Enquiries are being carried out, and a situational report will be submitted to the Procurator Fiscal.”

Dr Habib, who still works at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary, claimed he had spent years raising concerns about patient safety but repeatedly failed to get action from health chiefs and politicians.

Speaking publicly at a press conference in Glasgow, he said: “I know that today I am putting my career on the line to demand accountability and for the public to know the full extent of this cover-up.

“I have tried my very best to use the procedures, to go to every institution, but they all failed to act robustly as they should have, failing to investigate or take the appropriate precautions.

“I believe that NHS Grampian should face an investigation for corporate homicide.”

The surgeon formally raised concerns about excessive deaths during surgery in July 2021 and subsequently contacted Police Scotland, the Crown Office and Scottish Government.

He wrote to then First Minister Humza Yousaf in June 2023 and to John Swinney in October 2024, November 2025 and May this year.

But he claimed his warnings were ignored and alleged a “cover-up on an industrial scale”.

He said: “NHS Grampian are holding the key to the Pandora’s box and I believe they are deliberately not opening the box.”

His lawyer, Aamer Anwar, said the consultant had been driven to speak out because of his duty to protect patients.

Anwar issued a statement on Dr Habib’s behalf, which stated: “Catastrophically, the operating theatre he worked in at times could be described as a slaughterhouse, which killed through incompetence and negligence, while not giving a damn for accountability.”

The allegations have plunged NHS Grampian into another crisis just days after a damning Healthcare Improvement Scotland report exposed widespread failures in the management and leadership of its medical workforce.

The watchdog identified serious weaknesses across the health board’s acute services following concerns that children had been repeatedly put at risk.

Scotland’s Patient Safety Commissioner Karen Titchener said she needed independent reassurance that patients were safe.

Referring to the unpublished review, she said: “If this review is right, then 19 families have lost someone that should still be alive today.”

She also questioned why Dr Habib’s repeated warnings appeared to have gone unresolved.

She said: “He followed due process. He thought he had spoken to everybody, but yet he still feels that nobody acted.

“No one took ownership of it and followed it through to the finish.”

The scandal sparked heated exchanges at Holyrood, where Scottish Labour leader Michael Marra accused First Minister John Swin ney of failing to act.

He told MSPs: “Four times Dr Habib wrote to Scottish ministers, three times to yourself, First Minister, seeking help for the people in his care.

“Nothing was done to stop the deaths. Nothing.”

Scottish Conservative leader Russell Findlay accused Swinney of “refusing to take responsibility for this growing scandal”.

But Swinney rejected accusations of a cover-up and insisted the allegations were “of the gravest concern”.

He said he had only personally seen Dr Habib’s letters for the first time on Thursday, explaining they had been handled by officials and referred to the appropriate authorities.

He said: “The normal practices have been followed whereby expressions of concern about clinical practice are addressed by the relevant bodies.”

Health Secretary Angela Constance also insisted she had only learned of the allegations on Thursday and maintained that Aberdeen Royal Infirmary and Dr Gray’s Hospital in Elgin were safe.

She said there were legitimate questions about why the 2022 expert review had never been published.

A specialist team has now been sent into NHS Grampian to provide intensive support.

Anwar has called for health board chief executive Laura Skaife-Knight to resign.

But she insisted investigations had already taken place, with some work continuing.

She said: “Any new evidence or information will be carefully considered, and NHS Grampian will continue to respond through the appropriate clinical, governance and legal processes.”

She added that patient confidentiality had to be respected and that appropriate procedures were followed when reviews identified problems with care.

A Crown Office spokesperson confirmed the investigation remained ongoing, saying: “The concerns raised by Dr Habib were taken seriously by COPFS, with confirmation from Police Scotland that an inquiry was under way.”

The Scottish Government said it recognised the whistleblower’s courage and insisted it had repeatedly raised his concerns with NHS Grampian and Healthcare Improvement Scotland.

A spokesperson added: “There were clear failures in the former medical leadership and in how concerns were being addressed within NHS Grampian.”