Scottish Pub Stories: 'I'd often sat here thinking, I could make something of this'

Paul Henderson was enjoying a few pints and watching the rugby at his local pub in Edinburgh when he spotted a sign that would change his life.

For years, he had entertained the idea of running a pub of his own. Now an opportunity had appeared at Joseph Pearce, the historic bar on Elm Row, just a minute’s walk from his home.

Paul decided to apply: “I thought, why not give it a chance, and applied to Star Pubs. I had had a few pints, but I’d like to think it was an informed decision.”

Within months, he had left a career spanning more than two decades in education and social care and was preparing to reopen one of Edinburgh’s best-known neighbourhood pubs.

He had started his working life in hospitality, managing a golf club bar before moving on but the idea of running his own pub never disappeared.

“Joseph Pearce was my local. I’d come along here with the dog, come along here with my partner, come and watch the rugby, and, you know, it’s just been a good place where I’d come for a pint. I’d often sat here thinking, you know, I could make something of this. It was a little bit of a dream, not knowing that there was going to be an opportunity come up.”

Scottish Pub Stories: 'I'd often sat here thinking, I could make something of this'

Standing at 23 Elm Row, near the top of Leith Walk, Joseph Pearce occupies part of a Georgian terrace designed by William Henry Playfair in 1821. The Category A-listed building is part of the grand classical architecture of Edinburgh’s New Town.

The pub traces its history to 1898. The words ‘Joseph Pearce Wine & Spirit Merchant’ remain above the entrance, recalling its earlier life as a grocer’s and drinks merchant.

Its burgundy frontage and pavement tables are familiar sights on the route to Leith.

This summer, Heineken-owned Star Pubs invested £280,000 in a refurbishment, restoring the exterior and updating the interior while retaining original features.

Paul helped shape the design before taking over in late July, just ahead of the Edinburgh Festival.

The renovation also created a lounge dining area, with small plates, burgers, curries and traditional pub dishes on the menu.

“It’s really warm, it’s really cosy, and it’s really traditional. It suits the listed building that it’s in.”

Scottish Pub Stories: 'I'd often sat here thinking, I could make something of this'

For Paul, the more important task was bringing back the people who regarded the pub as their own.

“What’s lovely is most people that you speak to in Edinburgh, and especially from this area, have some sort of link to Joseph Pearce. So they’ll come in and say, ‘My granddad drank here’, or we’ve got an older couple that come in quite frequently, and they met here 35 years ago.”

“We’ve had three different wedding parties come in, either the day before or the day after their wedding, to gather here, because this is where they met and they had first dates. So, they want Joseph Pearce to be part of their story. It really is part of this local area.”

Paul reinstated the pub’s book group and welcomed running clubs and community organisations.

There is a Monday quiz, live music on Thursdays and new Sing-Along Sundays. A refurbishment can unsettle customers whose routines are tied to a familiar bar.

“I think for me, one of the biggest achievements was getting the old regulars back. I think that can be a real risk, that people, you know, can be a bit anxious about change when somethings been a big part of their life. And we’ve got all the old regulars back, as well as lots of new regulars, and a really diverse crowd as well, from young to old.”

He credits his social care career with teaching him how to listen and make strangers feel welcome.

“I think a big part of it is having the people skills. That’s the main thing. Being able to talk to people, to be an active listener, to be able to listen to people’s problems, and I suppose just not be judgemental and just, like a pub for all, just be welcoming, I think is a really important thing about that.”

His return also comes at a time of change for Edinburgh’s pubs.

The city’s huge visitor economy has shifted some traditional drinking areas towards tourists, while Leith Walk has become increasingly popular for an evening out.

“I think in Edinburgh, you’ve seen some areas which were traditionally where locals would go, turning into a bit more touristy, and new areas sort of popping up for locals to go for pub tours and to go and enjoy hospitality. And Leith Walk is one of those places.”

Joseph Pearce benefits from city-centre visitors while remaining rooted in a residential neighbourhood.

“I’m a big believer in my core business being the locals to the pub. So very much a community pub, but I want it to be, like, the local social spot for everyone. So that’s my core business, but obviously on top of that we really welcome anyone, whether they’re people here for a night, tourists here for a festival, you know, we’re just open for all.”

His experience has also made him optimistic about the future of pubs. Despite closures and rising costs, he believes good service, entertainment and investment can still bring customers through the door. He is particularly encouraged by the staff he has recruited.

Some work in the bar alongside established careers, drawn by the social contact rather than the need for a second job.

“I’ve got a teacher, a film producer, someone who tests blood for the NHS, someone who works for HMRC, who all just might do one shift a week or one shift a fortnight, but they love working behind the bar.”

Running Joseph Pearce has nevertheless been all-consuming. Paul took over through Star Pubs’ Just Add Talent programme, which provides training and business systems, but the day-to-day responsibility for staff and customers is his.

“Opening a pub does take up a lot of your time, and I have had very little time in this process. I’ve had one full day off.”

Living so close helps. He can open the pub, walk his Romanian rescue dog Pablo, head home for dinner and return for the evening crowd. He is keen to be a familiar presence behind the bar rather than a manager hidden in an office.

The experience has left him thinking about whether Joseph Pearce might be the beginning of something bigger.

“Admittedly, I have got the bug, and I mentioned to my business manager that I would be interested in taking on other pubs, either in this area or elsewhere in Edinburgh.”

For now, though, he is running the pub where he once sat watching the rugby, wondering what it might be like to be on the other side of the bar.

“I definitely love this life. I love this pub, and I just, yeah, onwards and upwards. I would do more in the future.”