A report recommending sweeping changes to the benefits system has been published - but it’s unclear how much of it will apply to Scotland.
Alan Milburn’s report From a Welfare State to a Working State: A new settlement for the next generation, proposes ideas to get more people under the age of 25 off of benefits and into employment.
Published on Tuesday morning, it sets out plans to reduce the number of those not in education, employment or training from 13% to 5% by 2036.
Milburn sets out his ideas for a new system in the report, but notes that “the institutional answer will differ because education, skills, health and local government are devolved in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland”.
The reforms are therefore “necessarily most specific to England” but it is recommended that the underlying principles should be implemented UK-wide.
Milburn calls on the Westminster and devolved governments to “agree common definitions, a shared set of outcomes and a regular joint review of progress”.
While acknowledging that his recommendations will, by definition, apply mostly to England he lays out a set of proposed measures.
The 267-page report calls for an overhaul of the benefit system, with under-25s no longer eligible for Universal Credit, and the Personal Independence Payment (PIP) to be relaced by two funds, one for ongoing costs and the other for one-off expenses.
It’s also proposed that National Insurance thresholds could be raised for people aged 21 to 24, making those people cheaper to employ, and a call to double apprenticeships and expand college places.
While the proposals will have very little direct effect in Scotland, with any cut to public spending reflected in the share which goes to Holyrood via the Barnett Formula.
First Minister John Swinney said this week it would be “unacceptable” if the Holyrood budget is cut as a result of the review and any changes implemented by the UK Government.
It remains to be seen how much of the report Prime Minister Andy Burnham will seek to implement, with predecessor Sir Keir Starmer having faced a rebellion over previous proposals to cut welfare.
Another former Labour leader, Jeremy Corbyn, said: “I am very concerned by proposals to remove health-related and disability-related welfare payments from under-25s. Why are we forcing young people to choose between support and employment?
“They need - and deserve - both. These proposals amount to a sanctions regime, which removes the very support that young people need to get into work and live secure, happy and healthy lives.
“Milburn says the proposed cuts will not be ‘pain-free’. This begs the question: painful for who? Our society is defined by grotesque inequality and corporate greed: why are we targeting young sick and disabled people and making them pay the price for a crisis they did not create?”
The Scottish Government has already replaced a number of benefits with alternative devolved systems, though Universal Credit is still administered by Westminster.
The adult disability payment (ADP) replaced PIP, but faces a £770m funding gap by 2029-30, as part of a £2bn shortfall in devolved social security spending.
Education is also devolved, meaning the proposed boost in college places and apprenticeships will be a matter for the Scottish Government.
It was reported earlier this month that colleges need £2.5bn in extra investment by 2037.
Education secretary Màiri McAllan said: “It is important to note that this report does not focus specifically on Scotland and the preliminary report highlighted areas where Scotland is already taking a different approach.
“Scotland already supports young people through initiatives such as My World of Work and significant numbers of young apprenticeships.”
Reform UK’s Thomas Kerr MSP said: “Labour, the Tories and the SNP have created a lost generation on the dole. The Milburn Report shows that almost one million people aged 16-24 are currently not in education, employment or training. That’s countless young lives ruined by ineffective politicians more obsessed with hand-outs, not hand-ups.”
Scottish Greens shadow cabinet secretary for health, Kayleigh Kinross-O’Neill said: “Sickness and disability do not wait until a person’s 25th birthday to become an active challenge in everyday life. Any move that reduces support for young disabled people only widens the gap they face in participating in society.
“On average, it costs a family with a disabled or seriously ill child around £3000 to £7000 more in outgoings per year. The health element of benefit claims goes directly towards the vital support they need to survive.
“For young disabled people trying to live any sort of independent life, being eligible to claim financial support can be the catalyst to help them remain in education or work, rather than deterring them.
“Once again, this UK Labour government is opting to shamefully target a vulnerable group with another cost-cutting exercise, instead of balancing the books by introducing measures like a proper wealth tax, or ensuring the richest people and organisations who can pay their fair share will put their short arms in their deep pockets.”
Allen Simpson, Chief Executive of UKHospitality, said: “The Milburn review has identified the right solutions to fix the NEETs crisis and recognised that hospitality is a critical sector to deliver on this ambition, as the largest employer of young people in the country.
“We’ve got to get on with it. Already, 100,000 jobs have been lost in hospitality because of rising employment costs. To unlock thousands of job opportunities for young people, hospitality’s tax burden, the highest in the economy, needs to come down.
“The Milburn review’s recommendation to double the employer NICs threshold for hospitality is the right one. It would be an immediate shot in the arm for job creation, protecting 240,000 hospitality jobs and driving thousands more job opportunities.
“Alan Milburn was asked a question and has given the right answer. It needs to be implemented. I hope the Government recognises the importance of urgently doing so and commits to increasing the employers NICs threshold for hospitality from April.”