Green energy entrepreneur Dale Vince has branded the Rosebank oil field a “last gasp” for the North Sea, arguing that the development would do nothing to improve Britain’s energy security or reduce household bills.
The Ecotricity founder and Labour donor has challenged claims from Reform UK’s deputy leader Richard Tice that blocking the project would threaten thousands of jobs.
Vince said the field, located north-west of Shetland, would produce relatively little oil compared with Britain’s overall consumption, while the renewable energy industry offered greater opportunities for employment.
Writing on LinkedIn, he said: “Rosebank is a tiny oil field - it holds just six to twelve months of total UK consumption. That’s it. It can’t help our energy security - as the oil will not land here.
“And it can’t bring our energy bills down by even a penny. As for jobs, 1400 is not “thousands” and the green economy that Tice opposes at every turn - already employs 500k people - and is growing four times as fast as the conventional economy.”
He added: “Our North Sea oil and gas is all but run out - Rosebank is a last gasp - good for nothing except for shareholders and venal politicians to bang on about as if our future depends on it.”
His intervention comes as more than 75 Labour MPs have urged Prime Minister Andy Burnham to reject Rosebank on climate grounds.
Tice has warned that refusing approval would damage Britain’s offshore energy industry and put skilled jobs at risk.
Vince has drawn a distinction between Rosebank and the Jackdaw gas field, which received government approval last month and has now begun production.
He said: “Jackdaw had a logic to it that Rosebank is missing - self supply.
“Rosebank has little if anything to offer us and definitely not oil - which will all go straight to ‘international markets’.
“A handful of jobs and some illusory tax revenues - that’s what it has to offer - along with busting our carbon commitments.
“Consenting Jackdaw was pragmatic - refusing Rosebank would be equally so”
Rosebank is predominantly an oil development, although it would also produce natural gas for the UK supply network. Its oil would be sold at international market prices rather than reserved for British consumers.
The project is operated by Adura, the North Sea joint venture between Equinor and Shell, alongside Ithaca Energy.
Developers say the £8.7 billion investment would support skilled employment, generate tax revenues and sustain businesses across the Scottish energy supply chain.
Aberdeen & Grampian Chamber of Commerce has also urged ministers to approve the development, with more than 1,000 North Sea workers signing an open letter to the Prime Minister.
Vince previously suggested further North Sea production could make economic sense if accompanied by price controls to protect consumers from international market volatility.
He has since indicated that he would consider financially supporting a legal challenge if Rosebank receives approval.
The field was originally approved in 2023, but the Court of Session ruled in January 2025 that the consent was unlawful because the environmental assessment had failed to account for emissions from burning the oil and gas produced.
A fresh government decision is required before production can begin, with ministers expected to determine Rosebank’s future before the end of the year.