A housing development described as a legacy for the 2014 Glasgow Commonwealth Games has been described as instead representing “institutional failure and avoidable human suffering”.
The Athletes’ Village in Dalmarnock was constructed for the sporting event as a regenerative project for one of the most deprived areas in the city.
The properties constructed on the site were used by the athletes during the Games and subsequently converted for permanent residential use and transferred into a mixed tenure community comprising social housing and privately owned homes.
However, residents have long complained of issues within the properties including damp and mould, flooding and drainage problems, and structural deterioration.
A new report by the Dalmarnock Village Housing Campaign, in conjunction with the Bridgeton Citizens’ Advice Bureau has condemned years of “systemic failures” with the development, having surveyed 89 homes as well as carrying out oral history interviews, examined photographic evidence and engaged with the community.
Of those surveyed, who included residents renting from Wheatley Homes Glasgow, Thenue Housing Association and West of Scotland Housing Association as well as home owners, 96.6% said they had experienced at least one problem.
More than half (50.6%) of respondents reported mould, while 53.9% reported damp. In total 64% they had experienced leaks or flooding or poor plumbing, with more than half having issues with fittings such as windows and doors.
Eileen Gallagher, a Wheatley Homes tenant, said: “I have had in the region of about ten floods I would say… there’s been loads of leaks, there’s been loads of issues with the plumbing itself. The drainage – basically the build quality of the whole house has just been terrible if I am being completely honest.
“The second was probably the one that was the worst if I’m being honest. I’m lying in my bed, it’s about half past four in the morning and all I can hear is water, but we’ve got the VELUX windows on the roof, so I’m going: ‘Is that the rain?’ And obviously it’s not the rain.
“By the time I got up, the whole floor is soaked. It’s run all the way down to the second floor and it started to come down to the bottom floor… It was just a
nightmare.”
Almost two-thirds of residents reported a deterioration in their mental health because of the issues.
Kirsty Sinclair said: “You’re scared to go home because you don’t know if something else is burst when you get in… it deteriorates your mental health so much when you know
every day you’re going home from work to a mouldy house, you know? You’re going to need to go in and try scrub with more bleach to take the horrible smell
away… You don’t want to go home sometimes – because like, ‘going home to this tip again’.”
More than half of survey respondents (51.7%) reported that housing conditions had negatively affected the physical health of at least one member of their household. Among households containing at least one person with a disability, this figure rose to 61.9%.
Breathing difficulties were the most reported health issue, affecting 29.2% of respondents, followed by asthma (20.2%) and chest infections (16.9%).
The author of the report, Dr James Patrick Ferns, said: “Taken together, the evidence presented in this briefing paints an unmistakable picture of a community that has spent years living with serious housing failures while the institutions responsible for addressing them repeatedly failed to provide lasting solutions.
“There is a limit to what can reasonably be attributed to bad luck. Dalmarnock Village is living through the consequences
of prolonged institutional failure.
“The physical condition of homes alone should have prompted decisive intervention years ago.
“Persistent flooding, damp, mould, defective ventilation, structural deterioration and recurring repair failures were not short-lived defects, but problems that persisted year after year until they became part of everyday life.
“What happened in Dalmarnock Village should never have been allowed to continue for this long. Residents have spent years living with conditions that demanded action, carrying consequences that were never theirs to bear, and fighting simply to secure the standard of home they should have been able to take for granted.
“Their experiences now demand more than sympathy or acknowledgement. They demand an answer to the failures documented here, and a reckoning with the housing system that allowed them to persist for so long.”
The Wheatley Homes Glasgow, Thenue Housing Association and West of Scotland Housing Association acknowledged issues in the past and apologised, but said the report “does not reflect the Village as it is today”, adding that many of its claims date back several years and that the interviews were carried out around a year ago.
A spokesperson for the housing associations told Scottish Housing News: “There were issues with some homes in the past, including problems linked to the original construction. We’re sorry tenants have had to deal with them.
“But this report does not reflect the Village as it is today. Many of the claims date back several years, and the interviews were carried out around a year ago.
“The report is based on the experiences of a very small number of residents. Our evidence from across the Village shows this is not representative of the wider picture today.
“We are aware of only a small number of outstanding repairs, which are being fixed.
“The three housing associations are working together to complete this work and provide safe, good-quality homes.”