Edinburgh's Argyle House moves closer to demolition as deadline set

The future of the Edinburgh office block made famous by Netflix drama Dept. Q is moving towards a decision, with the public now invited to comment on plans to demolish it.

Edinburgh City Council has formally advertised two applications covering the redevelopment of Argyle House, the imposing concrete building beneath Edinburgh Castle.

The proposals would see the 1960s landmark replaced by 130 homes, a 244-bedroom hotel, 156 aparthotel rooms and around 9,500 square metres of office space.

Members of the public have until 4 December to submit comments on the applications, which were advertised on 13 November.

Developers Henderson Herd and Mayfly Capital want to transform the site into a new residential and business quarter, with landscaped gardens, pedestrian connections and public spaces.

The plans include reopening the historic Baird’s Close, creating a new route through the site between West Port and King’s Stables Road. A public lift would also improve access between Castle Terrace and King’s Stables Road.

The proposed demolition has proved controversial, with architects and heritage campaigners arguing that Argyle House should be retained.

Historic Environment Scotland previously concluded that the building met the criteria for special architectural or historic interest, but declined to grant listed status because redevelopment plans were already at an advanced stage.

Edinburgh architect Malcolm Fraser has described the building as “a distinguished modernist building” and argued that demolishing it would be “madness”.

The Cockburn Association has also raised concerns about the environmental impact of removing the extensive concrete structure and called for proper consideration of refurbishment and reuse.

Argyle House is occupied by technology businesses, including CodeBase, and has become familiar to an international television audience as the headquarters of the fictional police force in Dept. Q, starring Matthew Goode.

It also featured in the television adaptation of Irvine Welsh’s novel Crime.

The existing headlease runs until 2033, meaning demolition is unlikely to happen immediately even if the applications are approved by City of Edinburgh Council.