The Scottish Government is seeking views on three possible approaches:
- In-class restrictions – Restrictions during class time but access to mobile phones during break and lunch.
- Bell-to-bell restrictions – Restrictions across the whole school day: mobile phones must not be used during any part of the school day, including break and lunch.
- Restrictions should be left to discretion of the school.
Evidence reviewed by the government highlights concerns around distraction from learning, classroom disruption, cyberbullying, online harms, inappropriate recording and sharing of content, privacy issues and the pressure on young people to remain constantly connected during the school day.
In 2024, the Scottish Government published guidance to support schools to manage the use of mobile phones in schools. This was updated in June 2026, to further encourage education authorities and school leaders to limit the personal use of mobile phones in their schools.
This could include a full ban in schools during the school day.
The guidance is non-statutory which means that education authorities and schools must consider it but can decide how to apply the guidance. This means that some schools may have full bans in place while other schools may have more limited or no restrictions. Pupils’ experiences depend on which school they attend.
The Scottish Government has said it will make a law to restrict personal use of mobile phones in all of Scotland’s schools.
This consultation seeks views and opinions on the extent and scope of restrictions on mobile phones in schools, the impact of restricting use of mobile phones in schools and what exemptions should apply to restrictions on mobile phones in schools.
Responses to this consultation will help to inform the development of legislation on restricting mobile phones in Scottish schools. It is open to anyone with an interest in restrictions on the personal use of mobile phones in schools including pupils, parents and carers, teachers and other staff, education authorities and education authority schools and independent and grant-aided schools.
The consultation follows a report to Fife Council’s Education Scrutiny Committee which outlined work undertaken to explore the potential for phone-free schools across the Kingdom of Fife.
Initial engagement undertaken by the Education Directorate found strong support for reducing the use of personal smartphones during the school day to improve learning, minimise distractions and address issues such as bullying and filming of pupils and staff.
Schools have continued to operate their existing arrangements for managing mobile phones and other smart devices during the consultation.
Some schools - including Ayr’s Belmont Academy - collect phones in boxes during lessons, while others, such as Edinburgh schools Drummond High and Balerno High, have rolled out magnetic locking pouches for the school day. Pupil’s reactions have so far been mixed, with some praising better focus and others complaining about queues at unlocking magnets or communication limits.
In Dumfries and Galloway, councillors recently debated a 21-page policy backing phone-free learning in nurseries, primaries, and early secondary years, while some members pushed for a full bell-to-bell ban similar to Edinburgh and Moray.
A council consultation of over 8,000 pupils, parents, and staff in West Lothian found strong backing from parents for primary restrictions and staff reports of better focus. However most pupils favoured teacher-directed use over a total ban.